Letters
Reporting is biased, KSU
chairman says
RECORD–COURIER, December 15, 1997
I am appalled at the type of journalism that I have had to endure from
this newspaper. There have been two stories written by the same reporter
that can only be characterized as sensational and extremely biased.
The first was written in late November, titled "Rally seeks ouster of KSU
chairman," following the outside rally that Black United Students had at
KSU. The second occurred Dec. 12, following a meeting of the Pan African
Faculty and Staff Association, called by its Executive Board. The first
article never even mentioned that the previous chair of Department of Pan
African Studies, who is supposed to be retired was present at the rally
and spoke 10 to 15 minutes, in a very profane way, verbally attacking three
members of the faculty, including me. It was never reported that his remarks
were extremely provocative, and could be interpreted as inciting the students
to violence. The second article was written with extreme prejudice, with
a total disregard of the ethics of journalism. This second article
is titled, "Faculty peers: KSU department head should resign — Faculty
group echoes students' request." This title, along with the comments given
by the president of the Pan African Faculty and Staff Association is extremely
misleading. What your viewers have not been informed about is: l) the fact
that there were dissenting opinions, by some of KSU's most distinguished
faculty members; 2) the general membership never approved the statement
given by the president of PAFSA, and others on her board; 3) that the previous
chair of Pan African Studies was there again, making unsubstantiated statements
and publicly attacking my administration; and 4) the meeting was called
by the presideat for the purpose of getting input and a vote from the general
membership, concluded without any resolution of the issue.
This meeting was called for
the PAFSA membership only. Hence, someone invited this reporter to this
meeting. His news columns are adding further confusion and encouraging
and supporting a very complex and skillfully orche- strated campaign to
undermine the administra- tion and leadership of the current chair of the
Department of Pan African Studies. This repor- ter did not provide his
readers with sufficient information about the information that the current
chair disclosed, so that they might have a proper appreciation of the accomplish-
ments of his administration over the last three years. Moreover, this reporter's
suggestion that I am never available for comments after these meetings
is another way of misleading the reader. I am always available to clear
up con- fusion, when the reporter can be trusted to write an accurate and
balanced story. The board of Black United Students do not repre- sent the
opinion of all black students, and neither does the opinion of the Board
of PAFSA represent the views of Black Faculty and staff in general at KSU.
Furthermore, there are other members of the faculty of DPAS, notable Dr.
Kwame Nantambu, who have quite different views from those that have been
expressed in this paper.
This is a story worth reporting,
and the public has a right to know. Newspapers, however, have both a professional,
as well as a moral, obligation to inform the public accu- rately, objectively
and without exaggeration and distortion.
George R. Garrison
Chairman
Department of Pan African
Studies
Kent State University
|